Showing posts with label journalism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label journalism. Show all posts

Friday, April 14, 2017

Thank you, Dr. Clark

In the summer of 1996, I was a staff writer at The Vista at the University of Central Oklahoma.
I wrote an article about sidewalks. I quoted an official with the facilities management department. He didn't like that and he didn't like the headline (written by an editor). 
He fired off a letter to Dr. Terry Clark, the chair of the UCO Journalism Department. The official admonished me for taking him out of context (by quoting him). He also criticized the headline and my journalistic integrity.
At age 19, I was a little nervous, meeting with Dr. Clark. He asked me if what I wrote was accurate. I replied that it was. He didn't bat an eye and defended me from the criticism. I still have the critical letter and I still remember Dr. Clark defending accuracy.
Over the years, Dr. Clark challenged me, a student with poor study habits. He challenged me to defy conventional wisdom when necessary. He challenged me to work hard and "get the quote!"
He championed small, community newspapers like the one from which I started my career.  One of my most rewarding experiences was in Dr. Clark's Advanced News Editing. My assignment was to redesign a small town newspaper. The publisher was skeptical of my ideas but offered me a job.
After a class, he challenged me to follow through and finish my degree. Many years later, I would finally take his advice and graduate.
As time went on, I left newspapers for radio. Still lessons from Dr. Clark persist to this day.
My story is but a footnote in Dr. Clark's career. A longtime editor and publisher, he became a legend at UCO and around the state of Oklahoma. His monthly column  in The Oklahoma Publisher is a must read, critiquing newspapers across the state. He started the Oklahoma Journalism Hall of Fame, housed at UCO.
He never stopped questioning. He never stopped championing his students. 
On May 1st, Dr. Clark is retiring.  His impact can be felt throughout the state. Through writing a column for the Oklahoma Press Association, teaching at UCO or earlier at Oklahoma State University, Dr. Clark has made an indelible mark on Oklahoma journalism.
Thank you, Dr. Clark.


Thursday, May 01, 2014

What's in a headline?

A day after a headline in The Oklahoman trumpeted Kevin Durant as "Mr. Unreliable," the newspaper's sports editor has apologized for the headline, calling the phrase "overstated and unduly harsh" despite the Oklahoma City power forward's struggles in the NBA playoffs.
Mike Sherman thinks his copy editors "missed the mark" with the headline. I think the headline controversy is a bit overblown.
First, realize that the writers the rarely write or approve the headlines to their stories. I don't write them as a free-lance writer for The Noblesville (Ind.) Times. Being the opinionated guy that I am, I have given some unsolicited input. But, I'm not the editor. The only instances in which I wrote my own headlines were when I doubled as the sports editor and writer in college and at The Bethany (Okla.) Tribune. So, any complaints to Berry Tramel (the writer of the story) are misguided. Tramel served as Sports Editor for a time at The Oklahoman after I left (I was a part-time sports writer there from 1996-2000), but I doubt he makes the headline decisions as a columnist.
The headline itself was a bit over the top and probably written with some emotion after the Oklahoma City Thunder dropped Game 5 of their West Conference Playoff Series with the Memphis Grizzlies. Durant is struggling against the Grizziles' Tony Allen. Remember, sports writers and other sports media are fans at heart. Especially in the case of the Thunder, the frustration with Durant's play and the Thunder being one game away from elimination, it might have seeped in the decision-making process.
Tramel used the phrase 'unreliable' in the sixth paragraph after describing Durant's poor foul-shooting in the series. The copy editor probably picked up on that.
Some (including Sherman) think the headline gave readers the impression that Durant is unreliable as a human being and that it attacked his character. That notion seems silly to me. Some can't make the distinction, but praise or criticism of player in competition has no bearing on how they are as a person.
Durant had the best response to the controversy.
"It’s all good. I don’t really care. Coming from my paper back at home, that’s what they’re supposed to write," Durant said Thursday. "I didn’t come through for the team. So they got to write that type of stuff."
I doubt Durant enjoyed the headline, but he's probably more concerned with his play -- with good reason.
If Durant leaves for a bigger market when he becomes a free agent in 2016, this type of headline is tame compared to what he'll encounter in media markets like New York.
For what it's worth, Royce Young of DailyThunder.com wrote a great piece on Durant's struggles. It's a must-read, besides the 'edgy,' (read: lame) use of one profane word.

Thursday, March 13, 2014

Mashable uses poor headline for iOS critque


Tech journalism site Mashable posted a decent article about the pros and cons of iOS 7.1. Unfortunately, the headline is a tad misleading.There is some discussion at the end the article about "what's wrong?" but it is far outweighed by praise for the new OS changes.

Looking for links, Mashable?

Ironically, the article didn't mention the confusing changes to the shift key on the virtual keyboard. They missed the boat there.


Friday, April 22, 2011

Sloppy Writing or Sloppy Editing?

I've seen this a lot lately. A last name is referenced early in an article. Later in the article, the person's full name is listed. You can find an example in this article
(Look for the McHale reference).
Did an editor move a paragraph up or down or is it on the writer?
The Oklahoman late sports editor Bob Colon used to tell me, "Joel, it's the little things that will kill you."
Now, let me spell-check this blog post. :-)

Thursday, September 09, 2010

The Media Failed Us In The Qur'an Burning Story

A fringe church of about 50 people has driven the nation into a frenzy about Qur'an-burning, filling the airwaves and web and soliciting a comment from the sitting president.
Think about that for a second.
50 people.
They don't even have a website anymore because of 'contractual issues with the hosting company.' (read: didn't pay their bill)
Seriously?

NOW, BEFORE I GO ANY FURTHER.

These people are crazy. This is NOT a Christian thing to do. They are wrong! Wrong. Wrong. Wrong.

They WIN because we talk, talk, talk about them.
Just like the Westboro Baptist Church crazies to my west in Topeka, Kansas (who say they've already done the burning before.) These people would shrink into the background without exposure. They may not completely go away, but there's also a church dedicated to worshipping Jedis.

But, instead of actual reporting on the many issues of the day, everyone is riled up with soundbites from people who talk without having anything to say.

50 people.

(NOTE: I work for a media outlet that avoided the story until this week, when the firestorm grew ludicrous, when we made mention of the story and sane Christian leaders' reactions to it. MY VIEWS ARE MY OWN).

Sunday, January 17, 2010

The Technical Foul Heard 'Round The World

As you might imagine, Michigan high school basketball isn't something I follow, but I had to blog about it after reading two accounts of this game and watching the final seconds on video.

When the clock hits 0:00, and one team has more points on the scoreboard than another, the game is decided, right?
That's not necessarily the case, as the Macomb (Mich.) Dakota Cougars found out last Friday (Jan. 8). What happens after the buzzer sounds can be as important as the shots taken before it blows.
***
Dakota's Mark Morris capped off a comeback over rival Romeo (Mich.) by nailing a 3-pointer from as time expired to give the Cougars a 63-62 win.
What happened next will be debated forever.
Rick Desotell in the
Romeo Observer (FULL STORY), gave this account.

Reports vary, but the jist of the story is after Morris hit his shot he immediately started sprinting in the direction of the Romeo bench. Fellow players and fans followed and eventually wound up being a little too close and even on the Bulldogs bench. Words were exchanged and somebody got physical because the officials called a technical foul for excessive celebration on someone from Dakota, giving the Bulldogs two freethrows.

The story in the
Macomb Daily was very different (FULL STORY), making no mention of any physical altercations.

"The buzzer went off as the ball went through the hoop," Cougars coach Bill Snyder said. "There was clearly no time left on the clock."

Morris made the shot into the basket in front of the Dakota bench.

At the other end of the court, Cougars players, coaches and fans flooded the floor in celebration, believing, Snyder said, the game was over.

Snyder said he stayed on the court to help restore order; in the meantime, Dakota's players went to their dressing room.

Where
The Macomb Daily received their information is a little suspect. The article in that paper did not have a byline, so it's possible a reporter did not attend the game.

The Macomb article went on to quote Snyder theorizing that the"technical was improper" because time had expired.

Not so says the Detroit News' Tom Markowski: (FULL STORY)

According to Michigan High School Athletic Association rules, officials can call a foul, in this case a technical foul, as long as they have not left the court.

I couldn't find the rules online (most likely because they want you to buy a National High School Associations rule book).
When asked by Markowski about his possible protest to the state association (which was reported in Macomb Daily article), Snyder back-tracked.

"I turned it over to our athletic department," Snyder said. "We played last night (Tuesday) and we're preparing for our next game. Right now it's the furthest thing from my mind."

So, what does the video show? Yes, there is video. Local cable station WBRW televised the game and posted the video online (LINK)

The final play starts at 84:35 on the tape. The Cougars run the length of the floor and Morris hits the game winning shot (at 84:49). The Dakota squad runs down the floor (led by Morris) towards the Romeo bench. At 84:57 you see Dakota's number 23 shove a Romeo player (the Dakota roster on the web site is from last year, so I can't identify the player). The squad and fans congregate inches from the Romeo bench to celebrate. The officials try and move the team away. At 85:11, you can see the two coaches argue. At 85:17, Dakota's number 25 shoves a player.

What happened with the technical shots? The Romeo shooter made 1-of-2 to tie the ballgame. In overtime, Romeo dominated Dakota, winning the game 77-71.

Clearly, the video shows "technical-worthy" offenses from the visiting Dakota team. In accordance to the rules, the game isn't over until the officials leave the floor. That means the officials made the right call and maybe we can all learn a lesson in winning the right way.

***
LEFTOVERS: 1. It is clear that the Macomb Daily needs to do some better reporting. They didn't appear to be at the game (there was no byline) and only talked to the Dakota coach and a Romeo assistant. They didn't seem to get a clear picture of what happened. Much of the article was devoted to giving the Dakota coach a platform to argue his flawed case.
2. The Romeo Observer account gave a better picture, but added a little opinion too. The writer did not give a source or background on the rule.
3. It is admirable what WBRW does in televising Romeo athletics on cable. However, the broadcast team really takes the spotlight off the students when they continue to talk about the officiating. The amount of time that they analyzed the officials bordered on ludicrous.